Two recently published books – one on the Covid disaster and the other on lobbying for a high-speed rail service – offer contrasting lessons on relations between local and central authorities in China, writes John Burns.
“In essence, Article 23 is not an infringement on our liberties; rather, it serves as a safeguard against potential hazards to our way of life,” writes Adrian Ho.
“Whether or not the [monthly fireworks displays prove] successful in terms of visitor satisfaction, we can be sure of one thing: its negative impact on local wildlife,” write Michael Boyle and Victoria Amaral.
“The flip side of the director of audit developing a new national security hobby is that it will reduce the resources devoted to his proper function, which is ensuring that government spending is honest and effective,” writes Tim Hamlett.
“In the Article 23 consultation document authorities offer their interpretation of 2019 without considering the government’s role in triggering the protests, the underlying causes of discontent in Hong Kong, the role of civil society, and the role of ‘external forces,’ ” writes John Burns.
“The emphasis on secrecy and security in the Article 23 proposals is likely to strengthen the tendency of authorities, who are mostly risk-averse, to over-classify information,” writes John Burns.
The Messi affair has “provided a great deal of harmless media fodder,” writes Tim Hamlett. “It has also, rather regrettably, consumed a large chunk of the rather small period allowed for people to comment on the upcoming national security legislation.”
“A key takeaway from Asia’s election experience is the need to revisit existing media laws being weaponised to justify censorship and judicial tyranny,” writes Mong Palatino.